Comment & Opinion

Plarium on the Strategic, Operational, and Tactical levels of war in Clash Royale

Plarium on the Strategic, Operational, and Tactical levels of war in Clash Royale

The military "is a place where you're supposed to grow up and give up on your childhood dreams."

So says Guy Ulmer, Platform Technology Specialist at Plarium, introducing his talk at GDC Europe.

But luckily, when he was conscripted for his compulsory service in the Israeli army, his job was to monitor the usage of others on the computer network.

"Nobody watches the watchmen, so there was nobody to stop us playing Diablo 2," he recalls.

For Ulmer, then, the association between games and war has always been significant. But now, working at Stormfall: Age of War developer Plarium, that connection has been made even more explicit.

"Strategy games have a very great connection to war," he explains, and it's clearly a topic he has put plenty of thought into.

He addresses the three levels of war, as established by military theorist Carl von Clausewitz and attempts to map their significance in a gaming context:

  • Strategic: In defence, this is the base and force building aspect of the game. When going on the offensive, it's about choosing the best plan to achieve your goal.
  • Operational: Defensively, this relates most to economy management. In terms of attack, this is about high-level combat management.
  • Tactical: Defensive layout and manoeuvres, and individual unit control in battle.

What Ulmer calls the traditional strategy game flow sees the player address each of these levels sequentially, first defensively and then offensively.

Guy Ulmer on stage

But particularly with the shift to free-to-play and mobile, this sequence has been disrupted.

Both tower defence titles and build-and-battlers, to differing extents, lean towards the defensive side, with little or no scope for offensive planning or individual unit control.

 "I've seen people discuss the strategic and tactical levels of war in relation to games, but never operational," says Ulmer.

A lot of people call Clash Royale a tower defence game, but it's definitely not.
Guy Ulmer

However, in the design of many F2P games, it's arguably the most important level. Take Clash Royale, for example. 

"I notice that a lot of people call Clash Royale a tower defence game, but it's definitely not... you have to go on the offence if you want to win," he observes.

However, like many of its peers on mobile, it also limits the offensive strategy (only three lanes) and cuts out any semblance of attacking tactics (no unit control).

"So what is it about?" questions Ulmer. "It's about high-level combat management mostly."

So in Clash Royale, with the deck being "where the decision making takes place," the entire game is constructed around the operational level.

But what should other strategy game developers take away from this?

"Analyse your game, see where you can place it on the level of war model. Analyse your competition, and see if there's any blue water where you can create something new like Clash Royale," he advises.

For Plarium, mobile strategy games have moved so far from that traditional game flow that going traditional is, in itself, a way to stand out.

Gates of War is the firm's soft-launched, "3rd generation social strategy... going back to the roots, a strategy game with Strategic, Operational, and Tactical levels."

Features Editor

Matt is really bad at playing games, but hopefully a little better at writing about them. He's Features Editor for PocketGamer.biz, and has also written for lesser publications such as IGN, VICE, and Paste Magazine.

Comments

No comments
View options
  • Order by latest to oldest
  • Order by oldest to latest
  • Show all replies