This article was originally published on the KamaGames website.
It is unsurprising that with over 1.5 million apps currently available via the Play Store and App Store that it is becoming more challenging for developers to get their app noticed in such as saturated, “red ocean” marketplace - and that’s just the first step in building a sustainable gaming business.
In a recent Newzoo report, it was reported that gamers worldwide generated over $99.6 billion in revenue in 2016, an increase of 8.5% compared to 2015.
For the first time, mobile games were also taking a larger share than PC based games at $36.9 billion, up 21.3% globally.
The global games market is expected to grow with a compound annual growth rate of +6.6% going into 2019 which will see the overall market reaching $118.6 billion and mobile gaming $52.5 billion.
When looking specifically at the social casino games market, the most recent Eilers & Krejcik report estimated an increase of +13.6% y/y growth to $3.81 billion in CY16.
Combined, the top three companies accounted for 41% of the total social casino games market, while the top 15 companies accounted for roughly 82% of the total market. Mobile games revenue accounted for 71% of all social casino game revenues generated in CY16 versus 64% in CY15 showing a very clear growth in the sector.
According to research, advertising fraud would have cost digital advertisers well over $7.2 billion in 2016.
In addition to the compound nature of the market when it comes to the top three companies, research also showed that the top 10 apps generated $481 million in Q416 and accounted for nearly half of all the social casino revenues generated worldwide.
When using a “rule of thumb” formula that states in order to get an app into the Top 25 Apps on the US App Store, it would need to acquire 38,000 new users every day - and that’s a lot!
The impact of fraud
According to research carried out by the Association of National Advertisers and White Ops, advertising fraud would have cost digital advertisers well over $7.2 billion in 2016.
Keeping this significant figure in mind, it is surprising that the topic of the impact of fraud on user acquisition and that of fraudulent traffic, has not received more attention than it has done and is still, in many cases, being overlooked.
The subject of fraud has always been somewhat taboo, but recently the topic has started to be discussed more openly. KamaGames recently covered this topic at a talk given at the Pocket Gamer Connects conference in London. The amount of attention the talk drew led us to expand upon it further here.
Mobile in-app advertising is one of the youngest and fastest growing parts of online marketing and so there is very high competition combined with low market regulation. This means there is an ever growing range of opportunities for publishers and developers to be cheated.
In 2015, a report from VentureBeat stated that the number of games publishers and developers who said they were victims of fraud increased by almost two thirds. In 2016, VentureBeat again reported that games publishers and developers stood to lose up to a staggering $100m as a direct result of fraud.
The routes of fraud
Unsurprisingly the level of fraud is significantly higher for countries with higher Life-Time Value and where the competition for quality paying players is significantly higher. These countries are referred to as “Tier 1” countries which feature the United States and the countries in Western Europe at the top of its list.
At KamaGames, we encounter fraud attempts from multiple routes on a daily basis.
At KamaGames, we encounter fraud attempts from multiple routes on a daily basis. One of several routes that are seen more regularly is the fraud via traffic from affiliate networks and third-party agencies where it is more complex to see where their traffic is coming from as it’s far from transparent.
This is mostly due to the multiple entities between the traffic source and the publisher.
Incentivised or mixed traffic instead of non-incentivised
This is a common example to explore. A target user is playing a match-3 style game and sees a pop up that offers him “Watch a video ad, get three bonus lives”.
Most users will, of course, watch the ad not because they are interested in the video or the app which they need to install, but because they are interested in getting the three bonus lives.
This type of incentivised traffic is more than 10 times cheaper than non-incentivised which makes this type of fraud extremely profitable for some fraudulent networks as a lot of publishers and developers think they are buying non-incentivised traffic when it is the exact opposite.
So, how best to tackle it?
The easiest way to detect incentivised traffic is to monitor the player’s early metrics which happen just after install, no more than one to two days, and also metrics with high probability, metrics based around consistency of what 80% to 90% of organic users do.
The easiest way to detect incentivised traffic is to monitor the player’s early metrics which happen just after install, and also metrics with high probability.
For example, some games have “Achieve level 3”, in other games it’s the “Completed tutorial” event being triggered.
KamaGames know what the normal conversion rate for this metric is across their users and therefore any significant deviations (more than 10% to 15% for such high probability metrics) are an indicator of incentivised/mixed traffic.
To detect an incentivised event such as “Play 5 levels and get X in rewards”, KamaGames monitors the deeper metrics that happen less often and not as soon as the ones mentioned previously to detect incentivised traffic.
There are events such as “Achieve level 10” or “Open 2nd location” which our average user will trigger on the 3rd or maybe 4th day after the install (with the probability of around 45-55%).
By cross-checking several metrics, we can identify if this traffic has come from an incentivised event and is a result of a “Play 5 levels and get X” type incentive.
Imitation of high percentage of paying players
This is the hardest variation of incentivised traffic to detect. Typically, the publisher will see expected metrics for their user’s activity, including as well as good or even above average conversion to paying players.
Due to these early encouraging results, the publisher is likely to be tempted to increase it’s spend into this “high performing” network - only to find out that while conversion rates were high, total payments and the average payment amount (and consequently, revenues) were abnormally low.
This is actually mixed traffic as one part is non-incentivised traffic and the other part is incentivised purchases traffic. Typically - there will be a lot of minimal spend purchases (e.g. $1).
Currently, fraudulent traffic is being detected within two to three hours of the test campaigns going live.
To minimise the effect of such fraud, publishers should continually check the distribution of paying players by tiers and analyse their actions and routines after they made a payment. Most likely, these newly acquired players will not continue to play.
The last of the more common types of fraud is the selling of cheap traffic disguised as expensive traffic. Fraudsters are aware of the users’ Life-Time Value across the different countries and are manipulating the tracking platforms by altering the country of install (which is typically validated by IP).
Fortunately, there are few other indicators which can help to define the actual origin of install such as language, location and a mobile carrier of a phone collected by the trackers (or combination of those).
For the past few years, KamaGames has invested resources in developing its own anti-fraud analysis and optimisation system, which is based on years of experience and huge data collected over time. The automated system monitors a wide number of metrics to help minimise the impact of fraud on UA activity.
Currently, fraudulent traffic is being detected within two to three hours of the test campaigns going live. In 2016 alone, the system saved hundreds of thousands of marketing Dollars due to the early detection of fraudulent traffic.
- The level of fraud in the mobile app industry, and specifically in the gaming industry, is increasing year by year. Installing suitable solutions to minimise the impact of fraudulent traffic is a ‘must have’ for any publisher planning to spend on acquiring users.
- A significant amount of the source of fraud is coming from non-transparent third-party agencies and affiliate networks. This is why working with agencies you trust is imperative.
- Incentivised and/or mixed traffic instead of non-incentivised is the cheapest and the most popular type of fraud. Tracking and monitoring the early metrics in real or near-real time will help to significantly reduce the threat.
- Monitor a number of metrics during the lifetime of a campaign and pay attention to all deviations or irregularities.
- Work with the larger and well-known networks who work directly with the publishers and get the traffic via SDK and then pass the names or ID’s of sources straight to the publisher.
- Monitor any significant deviations or irregularities such as a group of users having the US as a country of origin but they are using an Indian carrier, or it uses the Vietnamese language for example.
To download the full report please visit this link.
To learn more about KamaGames visit www.KamaGames.com.