Analysing the App Store Paid Games chart
99-cent titles not (quite) as dominant as you'd think
Are 99-cent games dominating the App Store charts? It's a suggestion we hear fairly often from unhappy developers, so we thought we'd dig into it.
We've taken a snapshot of today's Top 100 Paid Games chart from the US App Store, and crunched the data to draw out some trends.
They include pricing, but also product lifespans, which publishers are having hits, and the balance between brands and own-IP.
Yes, $0.99 is the most popular price point on the chart, accounting for 36 of the Top 100 games. In fact, 64 of the 100 cost $2.99 or less. But interestingly, $4.99 is the second most popular price point, with 20 games:
In fact, the average selling price of a game in the Top 100 today is actually $3.20. That's low compared to what operators traditionally charged for J2ME and BREW games, but higher than you might have expected.
However, it is true that cheaper games are dominating the upper reaches of the chart. Let's break it down by ranking bands:
It seems to get into the Top 20, you have to chop your price, as Gameloft has done for Hero of Sparta (1) and Real Soccer 2009 (6) - both $0.99. In fact, 15 of the top 20 games are selling for that price point.
But check that sweet spot a bit lower down, in the 20s and 30s, where the average selling price is 2.3x that of the top 10 games.
While it may be worrying that recently-released big games like The Sims 3 (21), Doom Resurrection (23) and Rolando 2 (37) aren't higher up the chart, they are all selling at a $9.99 price point. For now, at least.
iPhone and iPod touch gamers certainly like their new games. 40 of the titles currently on the App Store's Top 100 Paid Games chart were released in June or July this year. Another 22 were released in April or May.
Just five titles that were released alongside the App Store in July last year remain on the chart. Is this a problem? Not necessarily - if we compare it to another industry, the App Store games chart is clearly more like the music singles chart than albums. It's a fast turnover.
The App Store continues to distribute wealth widely among the development community. 64 different companies are represented in the Top 100, and 17 in the Top 20 alone.
It's interesting to see which companies have several hits on the go, though. Only five publishers - and they are all publishers as opposed to developers - have three or more games on the chart:
New platform, same big cheeses? Between them, Gameloft and Electronic Arts occupy 22 of the top 100 places on Apple's paid games chart.
The pricing aspect is interesting here, too. EA is making a great effort to maintain premium pricing for its iPhone games, with an average selling price of $5.49. It might not have any games in the Top 20 today, but it's not being drawn into the price wars just yet.
Gameloft is trying a different strategy - more than half of its games in the Top 100 are selling for $4.99, but it's also trying the $0.99 price point with three titles, including the number one ranked game Hero of Sparta, and sixth-placed Real Soccer 2009.
Brands vs Own-IP
A common complaint about traditional operator decks is that they were dominated by brands, with own-IP titles rarely getting a look-in. How does the App Store compare? Well, it's a different kettle of fish entirely:
More than half - 52 - of the Top 100 Paid Games are own-IP that's new for iPhone, as the following table shows:
In fact, the outlook for own-IP is even better if we consider those we've filed under Mobile, as these started life as own-IP games on J2ME and BREW platforms - all of DChoc and many of Gameloft's games count in this category.
However, console brands are a presence on the App Store chart too, with 15 of the Top 100. And interestingly, they're maintaining higher price points than own-IP games - an average price of $6.12 compared to $2.32.
This reflects the desire of the companies selling console-derived iPhone games to charge higher prices, of course.
Is iPhone proving a lucrative new distribution channel for games from the casual world? Not at present. PopCap may have three games in the Top 100, but overall there are only seven titles in the chart that started life as casual games.
Crunching all this data is great fun, and throws up some useful lessons. Of course, to make it really useful, you'd want to factor in actual sales figures - for example, by what factor is a $9.99 game in the 20s or 30s out-earning a $0.99 game in the Top 10, if indeed it is?
Apple doesn't publish figures, of course, and it strongly dissuades (to say the least) publishers from being too open about how sales relate to chart positions.
Meanwhile, the exact formula governing chart positions remains an enigma outside Apple - this too would be needed to really make sense of the data above.
Even so, we think this snapshot is pretty interesting. Let us know your thoughts on the data and our analysis with a comment.
Post a comment - Please log in to leave a comment
Show: Latest | Oldest
chris powell | 19:18 - 13 July 2009
hey all. does anyone have a case study or two of a published iphoen app , or more interesting, iphone game, that includes earnings?
Josh Kastelein | 15:11 - 10 July 2009
Nice report - you pulled a lot of information out of that Top 100 list.
I recently examined the age of iPhone games and found that over half of all games were either updated or added in the past 90 days. However, the age profile varies quite a bit among game sub-categories. My article was published yesterday at Busted Loop (http://bustedloop.com/blog)
Thanks for the research - it takes a lot of work to put this stuff together!
| 16:01 - 9 July 2009
EA did actually engage in price war to a small extent - both Tiger Woods and need for Speed launched at 9.99 and lasted just over a month at that price point.
Vijay Shrma | 13:02 - 9 July 2009
Thank you so much for this article. People are really ready to spent a little extra then a dollar here if the product is good.
Market is never saturated for good products and original IP is welcome here is the conclusion here.
Your article has inspired me to add an extra dollar to my next game price which is under development currently.
Playing with paying: European and Japanese roll out in-app spending capsLATEST FEATURES
Don't chase a hit. Build a community, says Kiwi Inc's Omar SiddiquiLATEST COMMENTS
Don't chase a hit. Build a community, says Kiwi Inc's Omar Siddiqui 1