Mobile Mavens

How is Oculus Rift shaping up compared to Morpheus and Vive?

How is Oculus Rift shaping up compared to Morpheus and Vive?

The VR market continues to excite and frustrate in equal measure.

A good example is Oculus' activity at E3 2015, when it announced finalised consumer hardware.

However, with a commercial launch not due until Q1 2016, key issues such as availability and pricing remain to be confirmed.

With this in mind, we asked our VR Mavens some questions:

  • Did anything in the Oculus press conference surprise you?
  • Do you think this is enough to enthuse early adopters for a strong fall pre-order campaign?
  • Or will price - notably the price of Oculus versus the price of Morpheus, Vive etc - be the defining factor?

 

Sergio Hidalgo Designer and Programmer White Door Games

Founder of White Door Games, currently working on VR game Dreadhalls.

I was surprised with the Microsoft partnership announcement. It makes sense that they'd [Oculus] go for that rather than building their own gamepad, but I wasn't expecting it, and I wonder if this partnership will continue on other products.

RE: is this is enough to enthuse early adopters for a strong fall pre-order campaign? I think it is from the technology point of view, but it will depend on other factors such as price, content availability, and so on.

Well have to wait until Connect in September to know more, I'm afraid.

Price will be an important factor to decide between Oculus and Vive, but so will content.

While Vive allows for a larger area to be tracked, I'm not sure people who can't dedicate an entire room to VR might want to pay a higher price, so Oculus might be able to convince those people if the headset itself is cheaper.

Also, having exclusive VR titles of high quality will matter a lot.

Tom Beardsmore Creative Director Coatsink Software

After co-founding Coatsink Software Ltd in 2009, I've worked on over 10 successful mobile (iOS / Android / Windows Phone / Blackberry) game / app projects and (more recently) 3 console (PS4, PS3, Vita, Xbox One, Wii U) / PC games and 2 games for Oculus VR / Samsung Gear VR. I'd describe my primary roles as Lead Producer / Creative and Managing Director.

I was a little bit surprised by the Xbox stuff, but I think it's a really smart move and I think the Xbox controller makes sense. Besides that, it was amazing to see our game and company featured. :)

I was particularly impressed by some of the bigger budget games on show. They looked legitimately interesting, regardless of platform, to me as a gamer.

Oculus should launch with plenty of games

The interest levels seem to be reaching a fever pitch so I'm sure they'll have a strong campaign, but I'm looking forward to learning more.

The defining factor, as far as the games industry is concerned, will of course be the quality of the games.

Vive and Morpheus should have a leg up in this respect given their pedigree but it's nice to see that Oculus are putting plenty of effort in too.

Paul Colls Creative Director Fierce Kaiju

Co Founder & Creative Director of Fierce Kaiju Ltd. Formerly of The Blast Furnace and Rockstar Games.

I was also pleasantly surprised by the Microsoft news.

The Touch controllers sound incredible, their announcement is very welcome and I believe that this next level of input is a must for VR.

Whilst I welcome a solid standard controller in the box, It's a little unfortunate that the touch controllers won't be bundled, for developers that can have an impact on design decisions that we make.

Touch controllers could be key for Oculus

I'm eager to see more titles that push VR in new directions.
Paul Colls

I suspect that this decision wouldn't have come easily. Oculus certainly wont be the only ones with this problem, and going with a solid controller bundled seems like a necessity, given that PC users will have a wide range of input devices, there needs to be some kind of standard at launch that's acceptable for every type of game.

Overall I'm a gamer first and foremost, I was excited by the presentation and the titles that we saw. I'm eager to see more titles that push VR in new directions, with new mechanics and design innovation, the funds earmarked for Indie devs will certainly help in that regard.

Price will obviously be an important factor, but Oculus have some great people working there, they know what they're doing and I don't doubt that they will deliver the goods. I'll certainly be in line.

Guy Bendov CEO Side-kick Games

CEO, Side-kick Games, makers of Mini Ninjas Adventures for Kinect, Dr. Jolt, Romans from Mars and other exciting games.

http://www.sidekick.co.il

Content, price and usability are critical for consumers.

The early millions of prosumers may be less sensitive to price though.

Does this man care about price?

Oculus did address content with a nice new list of quality games and addressed usability with an easier "almost plug and play" with the Xbox One and Windows.

I believe price will become an issue only after the first few million units sold.

Barry Meade Commercial Director Fireproof Games

Yep, have to say I was nicely surprised by the Microsoft news too. I'm currently pairing my Xbone controller with my PC to Witcher the hell out of unholy monsters and it's already an excellent marriage.

As for yesterday [the press conference], for me it wasn't so much the content of the show as a sense of relief that Oculus are finally speaking to the public and having to commit to something.

It's the controllers of the future that I want to see released ASAP, and those Oculus babies looked amazing!
Barry Meade

For all the industry chat of VR being ubiquitous, the future, of huge potential and all that, in reality every dev and publisher is afraid of Virtual Reality.

Whereas, Oculus only have one job. Their passion has guided us all since their Kickstarter and three years later nobody believes VR will be a thing until they take the plunge, so I'm just happy to see them at least creep to the edge of the water.

However, it's the controllers of the future that I want to see released ASAP, and those Oculus babies looked amazing!

Kudos to Valve for that, they dragged the rest of the industry with them just by making embarrassingly good hardware, it's so positive to see everyone up their game.

If you haven't used Vive you may not get the big wow about why these controllers will matter so much, but I can tell you as a gamer and game maker these pads add a very rich layer of possibilities to an already scarily good piece of technology.

In five years everything could be different. That's what's so interesting about VR now.

Tomas Mariancik Designer

VR game developer.

It's exciting that Oculus has finally shown their input solution and the controllers certainly look amazing, but I find it quite unfortunate that they're not going to ship together with CV1, which will come not only a few months after Vive, but with inferior input, which might factor in the decision to pre-order (or not to).

Not to mention that it might result in poor adoption in games and applications targeted at the Oculus headset.

The hardware itself now seems inferior to the competitors.

Tomas Mariancik

What's also surprising to me is the Xbox game streaming into VR. It seems like an attempt to get people buy the hardware with support for large amount of existing content.

However I fear that this might negatively influence the perception of VR (or Oculus) - the real magic of VR is in being there - in the game, in the story and watching movies or playing games on a virtual screen hardly counts as such.

It might eventually come to the price, as the hardware itself now seems inferior to the competitors, but there might be other differentiating factors, such as hardware support and openness of the platform.

Oculus has large community of developers who have been making hundreds of experiences since the DK1 days, which cannot be said neither for Vive or Morpheus and I think it would be a good idea for them to utilize this rich set of very diverse content that has been built over the time as their advantage.

E McNeill Indie game designer

In November 2012, I quit my job, moved across the country, and started working full-time as an indie game designer. My second commercial title was Bombball for Ouya, Mac, and PC. In late 2013, I won the Oculus VR Jam with a prototype called Ciess. Now, I’m working on turning Ciess into a full game called Darknet, set to release alongside the Oculus Rift. It’s by far the largest project I’ve ever worked on.

So far, this whole game development thing has been awesome.

I agree with most of what's been said so far.

Xbox streaming, motion controls, a bundled gamepad, the $10 million dev fund, the final product design, and the new game announcements are all great news.

The fact that Oculus Touch will be sold separately is not so great, but not a catastrophe. (It's worth remembering that for many games, including many 3rd-person or cockpit-based games, a gamepad might be preferable to motion controls anyway.)

Lots of question remain; including about Touch controller and price

Of course, there are a lot of questions still left unanswered.

  • How will Touch compare to the motion controls of the Vive and Morpheus?
  • Are there occlusion problems?
  • What's this all going to cost?

Overall, I think the Rift is shaping up to be a strong competitor to the Vive and Morpheus. The Vive has the advantage of being first, but with the right price point, I think the Rift could take the lead.

Contributing Editor

A Pocket Gamer co-founder, Jon is Contributing Editor at PG.biz which means he acts like a slightly confused uncle who's forgotten where he's left his glasses. As well as letters and cameras, he likes imaginary numbers and legumes.

Comments

No comments
View options
  • Order by latest to oldest
  • Order by oldest to latest
  • Show all replies