'Ahead of the Game: Ethics of Modern Game Development' - that was the prosaic title of what turned out to be a passionate discussion at GDC Online 2012.
Interestingly structured, the topic was presented as a debate between Nik Davidson (currently working at Amazon, but a longterm developer of MMOGs) taking the moral high ground.
Scott Dodson of Bobber Interactive was the 'evil business man' role; although his monocle kept falling out.
Moderating between the two was Scott Rigby of Immersyve, author of books such as Glued to Games: How Video Games Draw Us In and Hold Us Spellbound and a motivational research psychologist.
Kicking off
All three participants were happy to step out of role, however. Indeed, Rigby started off pointing out that the game industry now employs the language of subtle control.
"Do players really want to be referred to as whales?" he asked. Davidson said Disney always uses the term 'guests', something he argued could change corporate attitudes.
He took a similar approach in terms of the way metrics - especially in free-to-play games - are changing the way developers make and run games, and look to exit their companies.
Pointing to early MMOG Ascheron's Call, which he worked on, he noted "We didn't track first day retention. People didn't leave after one day. We had people playing that game for years."
Go long
Short-termism underpinned much of this discussion, particularly when an audience member from Zynga asked a question about how you could raise such ethical matters in a company manner.
Davidson suggested companies need to be very specific about what metrics they focus on - the 'You become what you measure' philosophy - arguing it's better to look at longterm engagement and monetisation. Not only is that the foundation for longterm success, raising these will also improve short term activity.
"I think too many people are looking to build their companies quickly and flip [sell] them," he suggested.
Rigby said he thought Zynga had a great opportunity to turn its business around, as it has the best metrics and analytics in the industry. Having to deal with Wall Street makes the situation for the publicly-owned company more complex, he noted.
Killer whales
With his business monocle in place, Dodson argued there was nothing wrong with the concept of whales.
"Most players are getting to play their games for free and we're only taxing the rich," he said. "What's wrong with that?"
Davidson had plenty to say.
"People say it's all oil billionaires spending large amounts but we know it's teachers and truck drivers who are spending more than they should," he argued.
"Our market is suckers. Our industry is funded by mentally ill rich people."
This generated a wider discussion about whether people are good at working out the value of virtual goods, something Davidson underlined saying that states lotteries are using tax dollars to market 'opportunity' to poor people who are bad at math.
Dodson was happy to agree that there are harmonious and destructive cycles of play, but that game companies only had limited responsibility.
For example, he thought that parents complaining about their kids buying hundreds of dollars of Smurfberries in Smurfs' Village were to blame for the situation, not Apple or Capcom.
"We've slowly boiled the frog, the frog being our customer," counted Nik Davidson, with the example that the situation in Japan got so bad the government had to step in, banning the semi-gambling 'gacha' mechanic.
Bad chat
Moving on from free-to-play economics, the topic of moderating communities was raised.
"If we enable communities, we can't turn our back on what happens in them," Davidson stated. "We can police this, but frequently we don't."
He pointed to Riot Games (League of Legends) as an example of company with a highly competitive, highly male community but which was very active in ensuring its community was well policed.
Dodson echoed the business case for such moderation, saying even hardcore gamers don't like 'ass-hats'.
"One ass-hat spoils it for 100 players. This is extremely compelling from a business point of view."
Part of life
Concluding, the discussion turned to the broader issue of how games integrate within players' lives.
Rigby pointed to research that stated there wasn't much difference in terms of life style outcomes where people played games for 2 hours or 20 hours per week.
"But around 21-23 hours of play a week seems to be a limit to well-being," he warned. "Above that, well-being falls off a cliff."
Yet, he said the research said that only people with poor life satisfaction would spend such amounts of time playing games. It wasn't games that were triggering that behaviour.
And all three panelists agreed games are a positive channel for generating satisfaction in their audience.
But in answer to a question about putting this debate in context in terms of all the realworld harm that occurs though alcohol, cigarettes, guns etc, Davidson said "The difference is we own the playground".
"Games are an important part of people's lives and we have to think seriously about these issues," ended Rigby.
News
Contributing Editor
A Pocket Gamer co-founder, Jon is Contributing Editor at PG.biz which means he acts like a slightly confused uncle who's forgotten where he's left his glasses. As well as letters and cameras, he likes imaginary numbers and legumes.
Related Articles
News
Oct 11th, 2012
UBM's Simon Carless on evolving GDC Online, moving it to LA, and supporting app developers
News
Oct 11th, 2012
GDC Online 12: Spacetime's Gattis on why start ups needs lawyers and finance guys first
News
Oct 10th, 2012
GDC Online 12: Zynga With Friends on the creative process and coming up with new IP
Top Stories
Feature
May 17th, 2024
New release roundup: The best new mobile games from a battle royale to a console classic remake
Feature
May 16th, 2024
Behind the scenes: How adding sandwich offers to an idle merge game boosted three metrics at once
Events
Digital Dragons | Europe | May 19th |
GamesBeat Summit 2024 | North America | May 20th |
Mobidictum Meetup Tallinn May 2024 | Europe | May 21st |
Nordic Game Spring 2024 | Nordic | May 21st |
Impact 2024 - Indie Games | May 23rd | |
Morocco Gaming Expo | Africa | May 24th |
MomoCon 2024 | North America | May 24th |
Unreal Fest Gold Coast 2024 | Australasia | May 29th |
Popular Stories
Feature
May 14th, 2024
53 top mobile games in soft launch: Squad Busters, Battle Guys: Royale, Plants vs. Zombies 3, LEGO Hill Climb Adventures, and more
Feature
May 13th, 2024
Hot Five: Dubai's new Gaming Visa, April's mobile game charts, and Xbox studio closures
Feature
May 14th, 2024