The supposed strength of Android in the US has been called into question before most notably by Apple, which questioned the NPD Group's methods when it pitched its quarterly sales of Google's platform at a higher rate than iPhone.
The attacks levelled at Gartner, however, are somewhat more serious, with commentators cited in a report on Apple Insider suggesting the research firm has inflated Android's numbers in its most recent stats release in order to satisfy its own narrative.
Android anomaly
The discrepancy centres around the 25.5 percent year on year increase in Android's share of the OS market, despite a fall in share for some of its biggest exponents Samsung, LG and Sony Ericsson.
Its an anomaly Apple Insider claims can only be explained by a rise in 'Other' category, which has seen its share more than double since Q3 2009 according to Gartner's numbers.
"The huge difference in reported phone sales allowed Gartner to describe a huge category of 'Other' - unnamed phone vendors who the firm claims are now collectively selling low end phones at an astoundingly high growth rate well above the rapidly growing HTC and Apple, and incredibly far above the industry average growth rate," Apple Insider says in its report.
"The 'Other' category ballooned dramatically from 49.8 million units to 137.8 million, a fantastic increase that gobbled up twice as much market share as Gartner assigned to 'everyone else' a year ago."
Small vendors, big sales
It's suggested the only way Android could have garnered such growth is if Gartner is assuming the majority of 'Other' handsets are running Google's OS.
That's something the site takes issue with, given large portions of the obscure manufacturers lumped into the category sell their handsets in emerging markets for less than $100.
Though it's fair to say some Android handsets are priced competitively, the platform rarely comes in at less than $100 a handset.
"While Android has helped Motorola, HTC and Samsung to deliver popular new models, Gartner's data does not indicate that its fantastic growth rates for 'Other' Android makers are coming from sales of the popular Droid, Incredible and Galaxy models," the site adds.
"Instead, the vast majority of Gartner's reported growth in Android is coming from unnamed companies more obscure than even ZTE and Huawei, and all small enough not to figure into Gartner's top tepee vendor brand list."
The numbers game
So, if the commentators Apple Insider cites have a point, why exactly would Gartner be upping its Android share unnecessarily?
According to a comment made by an unnamed former IDC employee in response to an article by Fortune, research firms often adjust numbers to fit the view they're trying to sell.
He claims it's not uncommon for firms to use the numbers to deliver a set take on the market showing the balance tipping one way or the other rather than delivering the actual sales numbers, which might not present quite so clear a picture.
"The fudge is in the 'Others' category, which is used as a plug to make the numbers work out," he told the site.
"In fairness, we did do survey work, calling around, and attending white box conferences and venues to try to get a feel for that market, but in the end, the process was political.
"I used to tell customers which parts of the data they could trust, essentially the major vendors by form factor and region. The rest was garbage."
[source: Apple Insider]
News
With a fine eye for detail, Keith Andrew is fuelled by strong coffee, Kylie Minogue and the shapely curve of a san serif font.
Related Articles
Top Stories
News
12 hours, 23 minutes ago
PocketGamer.biz Podcast Week in Mobile Games E12 - Xbox's mobile games store and Unity vs. AppLovin
Feature
May 17th, 2024
New release roundup: The best new mobile games from a battle royale to a console classic remake
Feature
May 16th, 2024
Behind the scenes: How adding sandwich offers to an idle merge game boosted three metrics at once
Events
Digital Dragons | Europe | May 19th |
GamesBeat Summit 2024 | North America | May 20th |
Mobidictum Meetup Tallinn May 2024 | Europe | May 21st |
Nordic Game Spring 2024 | Nordic | May 21st |
Impact 2024 - Indie Games | May 23rd | |
Morocco Gaming Expo | Africa | May 24th |
MomoCon 2024 | North America | May 24th |
Unreal Fest Gold Coast 2024 | Australasia | May 29th |
Popular Stories
Feature
May 14th, 2024
53 top mobile games in soft launch: Squad Busters, Battle Guys: Royale, Plants vs. Zombies 3, LEGO Hill Climb Adventures, and more
Feature
May 13th, 2024
Hot Five: Dubai's new Gaming Visa, April's mobile game charts, and Xbox studio closures
Feature
May 14th, 2024